The pager attack is not the first time Israel has engaged in the planting bombs in civilian objects
By Alex MacDonald for Middle East Eye
Lebanon is still reeling from two waves of Israeli-attributed pager and walkie-talkie explosions that have killed 32 people and wounded thousands more.
Although Israel has not claimed responsibility for the attacks, pro-Israel voices have been quick to praise the attack as a prime example of the country’s skill at conducting surgical strikes targeting its enemies without inflicting collateral damage.
This is despite the fact that two children were killed and numerous civilians wounded in the attacks, leading to condemnation from rights groups who say the indiscriminate nature of the weapons violate the laws of war.
A source close to Hezbollah told Middle East Eye that the pagers were used by a ‘wide network of people, including administrators, medical workers, paramedics, media workers and other civilian members’.
‘They are usually used for directives, summoning to meetings, for emergencies or state of alert,’ the source explained.
But this is far from the first time Israel has used unorthodox booby-trap style methods to target Lebanon, nor is it the first example of civilians and children being maimed and killed using such weaponry.
Cluster bombs and landmines
More than a million cluster bombs have been littered across southern Lebanon as a result of Israeli assaults on the territory over the years.
Since the 2006 conflict between Israel and Hezbollah, which saw unprecedented use of the widely banned weaponry, scores have been killed in Lebanon after coming across them.
Many children playing in the region have found these unexploded munitions.
‘They seem innocuous, especially to the curious mind of a child,’ said Chris Clark of the UN Mine Action Coordination Centre (UNMACC) in Lebanon, speaking in 2006.
‘They’re small, they easily conceal themselves amongst all the rubble or the debris of the bombing. We find that children unwittingly pick them up and then, sadly, suffer injuries from them.’
Both Lebanon and Israel are among the 33 countries that have not signed the Anti-Personnel Mine Ban Convention (APMBC).
Israel occupied southern Lebanon between 1982 and 2000 and during that period planted hundreds of thousands of landmines.
By the time they left, roughly 37,000 acres of Lebanon were thought to be contaminated with unexploded mines and improvised explosives planted by different parties to Lebanon’s civil war.
As of 2023, mine-clearing activities had cleared about 80 percent of this area of explosives.
The need to protect children in southern Lebanon from both mines and cluster bombs has led to some novel solutions – including the deployment of clown troupes to educate them about the dangers of unexploded ordinance.
However, according to Mine Action Review, work on clearing mines has been suspended as a result of the outbreak of hostilities between Israel and Lebanon since October.
‘As a result, Lebanon is not on track to meet its extended Convention on Cluster Munitions (CCM) Article 4 clearance deadline of 1 May 2026, and at current capacity predicts it will not meet its obligations until 2030,’ said the site.
Bombs in toys
But a much more sinister accusation has also circulated since the 90s – that of bombs being dropped by Israeli aircraft in southern Lebanon intentionally concealed in children’s toys.
Lebanese newspaper L’Orient-Le Jour reported on the phenomenon in 1997, citing a number of examples including a nine-year-old girl who had her right hand shredded after finding a ‘big apple-green plastic jeep, with six big black wheels’ that blew up in her hand after finding it near her village.
They also mentioned the example of a child who was left with severe burns after finding a booby-trapped flashlight and another girl who was killed after exclaiming ‘I found a doll!’ before being blown up.
An officer of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (Unifil) confirmed to AFP at the time that the objects were dropped by an Israeli helicopter.
‘It can be a toy or have the shape of an ordinary stone,’ he said on condition of anonymity.
In 1998 a letter from the Permanent Mission of Lebanon to the United Nations addressed to the secretary-general also repeated the claim that Israeli fighter planes had ‘attempted to kill children by dropping thousands of booby-trapped toys on Lebanese villages and towns’.
‘The Israeli occupying forces have used this method through the years and continue to do so, the most recent example being when booby-trapped toys were dropped on the town of Nabatiyah, killing and injuring children and permanently disfiguring others,’ he said.
For their part, Hezbollah at the time said among the items they found were a golden egg, fluorescent yellow cones, a Snoopy dog and a talking doll they said was set to explode when the cord was pulled.
Israel denied the accusations at the time, calling the charges ‘despicable’.
Nevertheless, a report by the UK Foreign Affairs Committee in 2000 warned of the dangers of unexploded bombs in southern Lebanon, mentioning the use of ‘booby-trapped toys dropped by the Israeli airforce near Lebanese villages adjacent to the so-called security zone’.
Speaking at the UN on Wednesday, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres re-emphasised that ‘civilian objects’ should not be part of warfare.
‘I think it’s very important that there is effective control of civilian objects, not to weaponise civilian objects – that should be a rule that…governments should be able to implement,’ he said.
‘What has happened is particularly serious, not only because of the number of victims that it caused, but because of the indications that exist that this was triggered, I would say, in advance of a normal way to trigger these things, because there was a risk of this being discovered.’
In both Afghanistan and Iraq, the US dropped yellow cluster bombs and similar sized yellow food packets. The bombs and food packets were not shaped exactly the same; an adult could distinguish the two even though they were the same bright color. Hungry children were not quite so lucky.
“Children playing are frequently attracted to unexploded cluster bomblets because of their unusual
bright colours. The actions of the USA – dropping aid packets and cluster munitions of the same
colour over the same areas – remain unexplained to this day. This led to
fatal confusion in Afghanistan and Iraq between unexploded yellow BLU97 cluster munitions and the yellow food packets (see photo). ”
Page 12: http://www.streubombe.de/documents/german%20cluster.pdf
ed note– why are you so keen to change the direction of this conversation from what Israel has done in Lebanon to what the US did in Afghanistan?
WHY???
I have spent the last quarter of a century, since 9/11, reading news dealing with Israel and the Middle East, and in that time have developed a good understanding for how Israel’s defenders operate. They have many faces and tactics, and one of them is to insinuate themselves into a discussion of this type and engage in misdirection/deflection, as our commenter ‘TheTrueNolan’ seems to be trying to do.
As often appears on this website, no one ever accused the Jews of being dumb, and this is just one manifestation of that fact–they know it would be a complete waste of time to come into the comments section of a website such as this and engage in all the typically Jewy tactics of accusations of ‘anti-Semitism, so they try to shut down the discussion through the method of misdirection and of ‘hey, let’s not talk about this…Let’s talk about this other thing instead’.
I could be wrong, and I certainly hope that I am, but methinks that ‘The True Nolan’ may be ‘The True Noam’ in disguise.
UK& US did the same thing over Germany during WW 2 by the way
ed note– and why are you so keen to change the direction of this conversation dealing with what Israel is doing to Lebanon into what the US and UK did in Germany almost a century ago???