ed note–please see the attached commentary for this here.

 

Middle East Eye

 

A new 21-point plan presented by US President Donald Trump proposes a permanent end to Israel’s war in Gaza, deploying an international force to the strip and no forced displacement of Palestinians.

 

The report releases new details on the Tuesday meeting on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly.

 

Trump’s plan calls for the release of all hostages in one go and builds on a previous ceasefire proposal put forward by US envoy Steve Witkoff.

 

The plan presented would require Israeli forces to retreat to the same positions they held during the two-month ceasefire between January and March this year, followed by a full withdrawal once the ‘stabilisation force’ is deployed.

 

The plan envisions an ‘international supervisory body’ that oversees a Palestinian committee which would administer Gaza in the interim. The plan stipulates that Hamas will play no role in the governance of post-war Gaza. 

 

The report does not specify who would make up that Palestinian committee, but said that ‘The Palestinian Authority, the western-backed body that administers limited parts of the occupied West Bank, would have a role but Arab and Muslim states would like it to be expanded’.

 

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly rejected the idea of having the Palestinian Authority involved in any postwar governance of Gaza. Israel has also consistently affirmed that it has no plans to end the war in Gaza and is looking to forcibly displace Palestinians from the enclave.

 

Hamas has accepted several previous ceasefire proposals that were subsequently rejected and derailed by Netanyahu. 

 

The plan stipulates that there would be no forced displacement of Palestinians in Gaza, which Trump’s previous ‘Gaza Riviera’ plan would require. Israeli officials have consistently said they plan to implement the Trump proposal that was widely rejected by Arab leaders, a plan from which even the US administration has since distanced itself. 

 

The closed-door meeting on the sidelines of the UN summit on Tuesday was attended by Trump and leaders from Turkey, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Pakistan, Jordan, Indonesia and the United Arab Emirates.

 

 

Looming breakthrough

 

A ceasefire in Gaza has been elusive to the point where many experts and officials have just stopped short of calling the negotiations dead. Just this month, Israel bombed Hamas negotiators in Qatar while they were scheduled to meet to study a ceasefire proposal. 

 

Witkoff on Wednesday, during a talk at Concordia’s Annual Summit on the sidelines of the UNGA, confirmed that Trump had presented the leaders with the plan and said he was ‘confident’ that they may even announce a breakthrough in the coming days. 

 

Netanyahu’s stated goal of completely destroying Hamas, which US officials have said seems impossible, gives the Israeli prime minister a permanent justification to remain in Gaza. 

 

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas said during his video call address to the UN meeting on Thursday that he was ready to enter Gaza and implement Trump’s new plan, referring to the 21-point plan presented this week. 

 

As of late September 2025, it is believed that 48 hostages remain in Gaza, at least 20 of whom are still alive. All of them would have to be released together for the plan to be implemented.

 

Witkoff indicated during his talk at the Concordia summit that the plan accommodates all stakeholders, including the Israelis, but the Israelis have yet to comment on it.

 

Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan was the only leader to publicly comment on the meeting, saying the discussion had been ‘fruitful’.

 

 

No ‘Annexation’ of West Bank 

 

Trump pledged to Muslim leaders that he wouldn’t allow Netanyahu to annex the occupied West Bank, according to news outlet Politico.

 

The report cited six sources familiar with the discussion, saying that ‘two of those people said that Trump was ‘firm’ on the topic and that the President promised that Israel would not be allowed to absorb the West Bank’.

 

According to Politico, Trump presented a white paper on ending Israel’s war on Gaza, which included the annexation pledge alongside a plan for post-war governance and security.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from The Ugly Truth

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading